Season 40 (2023-2024): TBA
Season 39 (2022-2023): The Mousetrap; The War of the Worlds; Exit Laughing, The Trojan Horse
Season 38 (2021-2022): The Charitable Sisterhood of the Second Trinity Victory Church; Cloak and Dagger
----------- --- (2020-2021): Season Canceled Due to COVID-19 Pandemic
Season 37 (2019-2020): First Things First; Farndale Avenue […] Presents… a Murder Mystery
Season 36 (2018-2019): And Then There Were None; The Hopeful Hearts Dating Club of Oconto; Guess Who's Coming to Supper
Season 35 (2017-2018): The Case of the Fatal Farewell; Insane with Power; Wedding Belles
Season 34 (2016-2017): Murder Me, Murder Me Not; Harvey; The Odd Couple
Season 33 (2015-2016): Dearly Beloved; With This Ring; Two Comedies (Double Engagement; Regrets Only)
Season 32 (2014-2015): Woman in Black; Lizzie Borden of Fall River; Thanksgiving on Serendipity Lane
Season 31 (2013-2014): High Ground; Bull in a China Shop
Season 30 (2012-2013): Here We Sit; Tally Up; Let's Murder Marsha; The Drunkard
Season 29 (2011-2012): The Speckled Band; The Lottie and Bernice Show; The Complete Works of William Shakespeare
Season 28 (2010-2011): No One Will Hear You Scream; The Butler Did It; Saving Grace
Season 27 (2009-2010): Who's On First?; Murder on the Rerun; Spirit
Season 26 (2008-2009): Catch Me If You Can; Dead Giveaway; God's Favorite
Season 25 (2007-2008): Lend Me a Tenor; Complete History of America; Big Bucks
Season 24 (2006-2007): Lost in Yonkers; Good Help Is So Hard to Murder; The Book of Murder
Season 23 (2005-2006): Farndale Avenue […] Presents... A Christmas Carol; Crossing Delancey; Jake's Women
Season 22 (2004-2005): A Party to Murder; Bleacher Bums; Farndale Avenue […] Presents… a Murder Mystery
Season 21 (2003-2004): The Perfect Murder; Reserve Two for Murder; I Take This Man
Season 20 (2002-2003): Ten Little Indians; Lunch Hour; No Mother to Guide Her
Season 19 (2001-2002): The Hobbit; To Anna with Love; 1940s Radio Hour
Season 18 (2000-2001): Arsenic and Old Lace; Once Upon a Mattress; 100 Lunches
Season 17 (1999-2000): Sylvia; Murder by Natural Causes; Later Life; Coping
Season 16 (1998-1999): Halloween Screams; London Suite; The Truth About Cinderella; Cookin' With Gus
Season 15 (1997-1998): Diggin' Up Dirt; Clandestine on the Morning Line; Nunsense
Season 14 (1996-1997): Murder at the Howard Johnson’s; Waiting for Mr. Howard; Rumors
Season 13 (1995-1996): Anybody for Murder?; The Stenford Place; Summer One Acts (Close Encounters of the Third Grade; The Prince Who Wouldn't Talk)
Season 12 (1994-1995): Murder by Misadventure; The Cemetery Club; Playing Doctor
Season 11 (1993-1994): The Subject was Roses; Musical Comedy Murders of 1940; An Evening of One Acts III (Asleep on the Wind; Adamantine; Dear Mrs. Martin; Graceland)
Season 10 (1992-1993): Barefoot in the Park; The Odd Couple; 12 Angry People
Season 9 (1991-1992): Our Town; Blithe Spirit; Lie, Cheat, and Genuflect
Season 8 (1990-1991): Steel Magnolias; Love Letters; Love, Sex, and the IRS
Season 7 (1989-1990): Wait Until Dark; How the Other Half Loves; An Evening of One Acts II (The Legacy; Popcorn; Next; The Marriage Proposal)
Season 6 (1988-1989): Close Ties; The Sunshine Boys; Rehearsal for Murder
Season 5 (1987-1988): Send Me No Flowers; Squabbles; Chapter Two; Play On
Season 4 (1986-1987): Playboy of the Western World; You Can't Take It With You; An Evening of One Acts (Trifles; Save Me a Place at Forest Lawn; Who Am I This Time?; Bea, Frank, Ritchie, and Joan)
Season 3 (1985-1986): Crimes of the Heart; The Odd Couple; Harvey; Bus Stop
Season 2 (1984-1985): Plaza Suite; Last of the Red Hot Lovers; The Good Doctor; Dirty Works in High Places
Season 1 (1983-1984): M*A*S*H; The Mousetrap